War and Bromance

About once a year, I try to read the Iliad. Sometimes I make it through the whole thing and sometimes I get a little distracted and lose momentum.  I have a worn paperback of the Fitzgerald translation that I keep close and I have sampled the Fagles too. I like them both.


Everybody knows the general outline. A royal runs off with another royal’s wife which triggers a big war where a lot of people get killed, including Ancient Greece’s version of Captain America. Gods are messing around and arguing with each other while the aforementioned Achilles moves inexorably to his fate. Our hero has a contract dispute with his boss Agamemnon and goes on strike, whereupon his boyfriend gets offed. He comes charging back like any action hero about three fourths of the way through the movie and brutally avenges the death. After the Trojans fall for one of the dumbest ploys ever, their city gets sacked.

It’s all pretty awesome. The Iliad is a titanic pillar of Western literature and has been redone, reworked, translated, and adapted over and over again. There is an Iliad inspired story out there to suit any taste.

As far as which translation to read, I recommend just flipping through an edition and seeing how the language feels. For me, Fitzgerald is a great balance, economical and lyrical. If you want to spend a lot of time listening to educated people argue, just Google which translation is best. People spend a great deal of money and effort for those Classics degrees and they have to use them somewhere.

For adaptations we can look at two ends of the spectrum:


The Rage of Achilles by Terence Hawkins is packed with sex and violence and written in punchy, staccato prose. The book begs you to describe it as “edgy”.

For more sensitive souls, or simply to suit a different mood, is The Song of Achilles, a tender story built around the romance between Achilles and Patroclus.

And what about that most famous of bromances?  It’s fascinating to see how prevailing attitudes shape interpretation.  Every era puts its own spin on the relationship.  In some accounts, from less progressive times, the pair are simply close friends. For the really curious, an impressive non-fiction tome sits waiting on the fourth stack (aka, the Mezzanine). In The Greeks and Greek Love, James Davidson performs a thorough social and sexual survey of ancient Greece.  With the info in this book, you might finally be able to put the Achilles-Patroclus issue to bed.

David Malouf’s Ransom is a retelling of Priam’s mission to recover Hector’s body.  Poignant and poetic, it represents the Iliad’s immense potential for uncovering universal human truths.


In film, we have the clunker Troy, starring Brad Pitt’s physique. There are worse movies. Sometimes serious, sometimes ridiculous, this film is hard to like but somehow equally hard to hate.

There is much fascinating debate concerning whether or not the Trojan War was based on some actual historical event.  The documentary In Search of the Trojan War is a great place to learn about Troy’s discovery and the issues and personalities involved. It’s a story as dramatic as anything Homer could have written.



Filed under Uncategorized

8 responses to “War and Bromance

  1. Don

    Brilliant, Sky. A brand new version or rendering is in the offing, poetry-wise:
    Alice Oswald’s “Memorial.” One might think of it as a lyrical Cliff’s Notes abridgement (and be kind in that thought). Here’s what the oracular NYT’s has to say: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/23/books/review/memorial-alice-oswalds-version-of-the-iliad.html

    For the curious, we’ve got a couple of copies on the shelf waiting just waiting to be rolled into your home for, um, perusal: http://catalog.einetwork.net/search/i0393088677.


  2. I enjoyed this; thanks. I have heard good things about the Malouf and the Miller. I will get to them soon.

  3. Sky

    Thanks for the comments. I will be giving Oswald a try this weekend. I hope you enjoy Malouf and Miller. I wonder which is best to read first?

  4. ZZMike

    Yes, the movie left more than a lot to be desired. It left out the influence of the gods, which made the story just another ancient gang war.

    Homer wasn’t much for character development or back-story.. A synopsis might start;

    Achilles was really mad, because his boss took away his war-prize, the woman Briseis, and Achilles went into a dark funk and said he wasn’t gonna fight no more, and by the way, his mother was the goddess Thetis, so then……

    I read the NYT Oliver review. The second page says just about all there is,

    Going to the top of your piece, I think you have the right idea: some books should be read over and over. Somewhere, Nabokov said that you don’t read a book, you re-read it (“Lectures on Literature”).

    On the other hand, life is somewhat short, and we can’t re-read all the books we might want to (and there are more, every day, over the horizon).

    What other books would you recommend for re-reading? (I don’t know yet – I just now thought of the question).

  5. Sky

    Which books to reread? Wow that is a great question. I think that deserves a whole post. I think for me it boils down to two categories, stuff that constantly enriches, like the Iliad, and stuff that is just great to read. For me that would be sci-fi author Jack Vance or Herbert’s Dune. Oh and Dumas. What do you reread?

  6. Pingback: Troy | OVERTURKEY

  7. Reblogged this on AlfonsoHuerta's Blog and commented:
    I have been wanting to read this book for a very long time. I read the Odyssey in High School and have always wanted to read this as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s